@Pluton9
You're setting conditions to fit your view of things. How could you prove that this tweet only took active adventurers into account and not retired ones like Anya? You want to argue that they’re too weak due to their retirement to be considered, but in practice, retirement hasn’t weakened the members of the Hostess of Fertility, for the following reasons:
Omori tweeted that Tsubaki, Anya, Chloe, and Lunoire could defeat the Ishtar Familia without Uchide no Kozuchi. Tsubaki would take care of Phryne, and one of the other three would handle Tammuz, leaving the remaining two to deal with about twenty level-3 Berbera. Would you call that being weak?
If you're going to argue that the Berbera are weak, remember that they successfully defended Haruhime from the Einherjars. And speaking of that, if the Einherjars are so superior to everyone else, why couldn’t they take down Lena (level 2) and Samira (level 3) to overpower Haruhime? It’s becoming more doubtful that the Einherjars could win against anyone!
On the other hand, Hedin complained about Mia’s performance, but practically speaking, he didn’t perform any better than she did. She fought solo at the beginning of the battle, and Hedin was the first of the four to fall, despite being the last to join. So his performance was, at most, equal to Mia's, to be generous. Therefore, Mia’s inactivity hasn’t weakened her or the other maids at all.
Given this, if Anya (of the Freya Familia) and Alicia weren’t listed in the ranking, it’s not an oversight but rather because they weren’t meant to be included. Only Bell’s absence is controversial, but that was when his power was immense. As a unique character, it wouldn’t make much sense to rank him with ordinary characters.
As for Aisha, she received UnK at the beginning, but remember it only lasts 20 minutes, and the southern flank was completely overrun with only a few remaining. Also, all gods except four were eliminated by Allen, so before the Bringar arrived, Mikoto, Naaza, and the Berbera were already fighting outnumbered. With or without the level boost, the Einherjars should have been able to defeat her in those circumstances, but they didn’t. Why is that? Perhaps because she’s better than them? If you disagree, how do you explain that under those circumstances they couldn’t defeat her and had to send the Bringar to take her down?
Regarding the Loki Familia, the life of an adventurer is full of dangers. Doesn’t Ottar say that gaining power requires venturing out? They had to defeat Enyo, and that involved risks. If no one had died, Omori would be accused of excessive plot armor. Your idea of prioritizing self-preservation would be the same as letting Enyo roam freely, which obviously wasn’t an option. That’s the life of adventurers: they take risks, some die, but those who survive become stronger.
As for their level 7 being only a stat boost and not a combat skill improvement—in Danmachi, level indicates combat skill, which is why expressions like "the skill of a level X adventurer" are used. This rule is always followed; when have we seen an adventurer with a higher level but lower combat skill than another? Except for Bell, of course. It’s a very natural outcome: leveling up involves facing challenges, overcoming them means progress, and progress translates to higher quality. So, even though there isn’t an official confirmation, it’s logical within the series that Loki’s trio surpasses Freya’s in both stats and combat skills.
Regarding Allen and Bete, given how much you value stats, you should easily understand why Bete needed to beastify himself. Allen could have stats in the S range while Bete’s might be I, H, or at most G. There’s a clear gap that needs to be closed for the fight to be fair—that’s obvious. The interesting part for our discussion is the development of the fight itself, knowing who won or was winning, and whether one had a marked advantage in skill. Ultimately, we’re talking about combat skill, so performance is what matters. Too bad Omori didn’t show us the fights, at least this one, so we wouldn’t have to speculate.
But the fact that neither came out injured raises serious doubts about whether Allen’s skill is vastly superior to Bete’s. The same could be said in reverse, but it’s Allen who has to prove his superiority to give credibility to the idea that any member of Freya’s Familia is superior to anyone from another familia. If the evidence doesn’t support it, that claim starts to look like one of Omori’s typical hyperboles.
As for the conversation between Hedin and Ottar, the trio wasn’t level 7 when volume 18 was published. Yes, chronologically they were, as written in SO14, but SO14 was published after MS18, so it’s a typical case of reconfiguration. So, when MS18 was written, they were still level 6. Therefore, Hedin’s trust in Ottar for victory rather than himself raises a big question about whether he really believes he could defeat any level 6 in Loki’s Familia.
If you're going to say I'm being arbitrary with this reconfiguration idea, it’s no more arbitrary than your claim that not only was the trio already level 7 when it hadn’t been published at that time, but also that Hedin knew this and based his calculations on that uncertain information. Both ideas have a speculative component, but mine has a basis (the publication dates support it), while yours is entirely speculative, if I may say so.
@Rigel31415
The reason I mentioned the efficiency of the growth methods between both familias is that many believe Freya's method of fighting every day makes them better than anyone else, including the Loki Familia. However, it's the members of the Loki Familia who keep leveling up, while Freya's members are stagnant. So, whether conventional or unconventional methods are used, it's the Loki Familia that’s truly improving, raising the question of whether they would really be inferior to anyone from Freya’s Familia at the same level, as improving stats goes hand-in-hand with increasing combat skill.
In volume 17, there’s a confrontation between the two factions, though it’s mentioned very briefly. When Allen, the Bringar, along with Vanir and company were returning to Folkvangr, they were intercepted by Gareth, Bete, and some others who blocked Vanir's path, though it's not specified exactly who they were. Obviously, there are no known results, but they weren’t afraid to face them, and there’s no reason to believe things went poorly since the Loki Familia was intact in volume 18.